Last updated: 4 May 2018
Updates 2016-17: new biog out…on The Urbanist…@owenhatherley on JJ…Slate on her cheerful hurly burly (cached) featuring JJ: the opera, with Robert Moses looking down from above and JJ looking at her feet…JJ: the film (Gdn & Olly Wainwright | Observer & again | New York Times | Vogue | Jonathan Glancey | Architecture & Design Scotland; finally seen 14 Aug 2017)…also namechecked on Slate’s The quest to make the perfect place (cached) on New Urbanism and its attempts to recreate the small town in the city as an alternative to the typical suburb – sound familiar? …graphic novel style: the urban pastoral vs Byvandring.nu’s technocrats… Will Self and Owen Hatherley on JJ (report)…JJ in Netudgaven…Andy Merrifield on JJ (excerpt from The amateur)…Curbed’s illustrated guide…JJ at the dog park…Vital little plans reviewed…
Lots about Jane Jacobs at the moment, “American-Canadian journalist, author, and activist best known for her influence on urban studies”. A Google doodle celebrated the 100th anniversary of her birth on 4 May with accompanying hashtag #jj100, there’s a six month New York based celebration, a year long effort in Toronto and a conference in Delft for starters, plus the annual walking weekend. Is Jane just the American (OK, Canadian) Gehl-like Good Thing you can’t argue with?
Jane’s Walk (#janeswalk | @janeswalk | FB) offers a cornucopia of delights, including Jane’s Ten Big Ideas, a quick guide to Jane’s written work and a summary of walkability research. From coverage elsewhere, the Guardian ran two pieces, with Saskia Sassen on the day itself and a piece on Jane vs Robert Moses. US based Strong Towns has screeds of stuff. See also the Project for Public Spaces, Jane’s last vid and Treehugger on Jane at home. And what might JJ say about smart cities?
iSlate, however, weighed in with Bulldoze Jane Jacobs, calling for a stop to the deification and a re-examination of her ideas, which have led to “nearly all-white, aesthetically suburban playground[s] for the rich”:
Governments…spend millions on implementing Jacobs’ recommendations—making streets more walkable, supporting new, local businesses, de-emphasizing cars—and nearly everywhere they do, gentrification and displacement follow. Other less fashionable areas outside the downtown core are all too often left untouched.
So much so Copenhagen, with its swathes of almost identically tasteful apartment blocks shooting up all over, re-writing of Carlsberg’s cultural heritage and over-hyped ‘one size fits all’ lifestyle. Meanwhile its outer districts, and even more of Greater Copenhagen’s five fingers, are seemingly left to their own devices.
My results from Curbed’s Jane Jacobs quiz:
Your neighborhood is a work in progress.
The sidewalk ballet (the dynamic unfolding of the city’s life, a form of art represented by interactions of neighbours, passers-by, children playing, shopkeepers) in your neighborhood could use a few more rehearsals. Some Jacobs-approved approaches may have taken root—there are a few newer buildings mixed in with the old, or your neighborhood’s avenues offer a mix of shops, restaurants, offices, and residential space—but the neighborhood still has long blocks, or large swaths of only housing or office buildings that leave it quiet for much of the day or evening.
So, back to the walking, an invaluable aid for those who find themselves adrift. Jane’s Walk Copenhagen turned out to be a one-off (I know, I know…) in 2014, with four walks tending towards the playful city, but for 2016 we find diverse delights in Birmingham and Coventry, Ghent, Liverpool, London, Tokyo, Zagreb and Zurich, plus Haifa, Jaffa, Jerusalem and Tel Aviv (all in Hebrew). With a special shout-out to Eugene Quinn’s Funk ORF! (Vienna).